Anyone who knows anything about this website knows that we do not lack courage and that we do not avoid difficult discussions or duck questions. However, to engage intellectually, I have to be presented by a comprehensible statement but in the comments above, apart from nationalistic clichés about Russians being liars, I failed to deduct much else.

Good God, this is kindergarten staff! I have met lying Brits, lying Germans, even lying Ukrainians, are they „unrepresentative of their nations”? Whereas a lying Russian is representative? „Responsible thinking of a statesman” – indeed! Do you know no shame?

No, thank God, nations do not have characters. When we speak about such things, this is only a shorthand. One has to be simpleminded indeed, to take it seriously. Englishmen are supposed to be reserved and phlegmatic – have you ever seen an English football fan? Or do they leave their national character at the gate of a football stadium?

Forgive me but I refuse to lower myself to such a level.

you have no courage to face a reality of the possible coming war

you lack what is called a responsible thinking of a statesman

it is very sad.

then i can better concentrate on the essence of the writings

and it is much more constructive

to try to answer the question then to change the subject

so now alow me to get back on subject

for sources you may start with Marquis de Custine- a very good read on Russian

read Yakov Krotov as well

read anything you can get on Ivan the Terrible – it is Russia as it is today in its pure intact form

read also what you can find on peter the greate- you ll find it interesting
and may be after some reading you will start to see the essence not the just the apital letters :

because it is about mass killings of humans.

Nikolai Bedyaev on russian communism is a good choice for the beginner also.

It will help you to keep your eyes open and remember that only rubbish goes with the flow- love it))))

Communists resort to Russian imperialism and nationalism ideology for some time already. Do the google search on russian domain- you will be able to learn what any russian in moscow can just plainly tell you.

Kremlin propaganda these days is anti bolshevik and imperial: they made an effort to redirect it because the major success they had in the past with provoking and winning the war – was based exactly on nationalism of russian imperial type.

This is something any school boy in russia knows.

> communists want to confuse “Russian” with soviet – is an outdated strategy. And term soviet itself is obsolete in political language: soviets were desmantled for a long time already as you may know

Killers of millions were mostly ethnic russians as are the operators of today offences in latin America, Middle East and all over: ethnic russians

And they dont regard themselves communist even though i would still call em that sometimes.

An finally,

Michal

you never answered my question:

if it gets to war that your nation is constantly threatened with
and was specifically warned recently on the subject of nuclear attack on Poland:

what are you going to tell your people to provide them with knowledge and inspiration and to secure the national survival of Poland:

how will you call those who may level your cities with megaton nukes?

NON-RUSSIANS? Communists without communist features?

Your nation is faced with an existential threat

In order to survive you must be absolutely clear on naming the enemy ang providing the People with exact definitions

Please answer the question

This really put me in a pickle. Either I did not comprehend the meaning of the above or it is the highest concentration of nonsense I’ve seen for some time. Or perhaps this is a poem? Random use of capital letters and strange (modernist?) versification would point in that direction. So not knowing what to do with it, I will just limit myself to the parts where I can have a wild guess as to the supposed meaning.

„Leading Russian thinkers” and „numerous sources” are supposed to convince me of what exactly? To close my eyes and follow the sheep? I’ll leave that to others, thank you. Feel free to follow the thoughtless multitude (I like this Nyquist’s phrase more and more) of pseudo historians who can all be thrown into the same bracket: „from white to red tsardom”. What a lot of nationalistic twaddle. I will keep my eyes open and will remember that only rubbish goes with the flow.

The fact remains that the communists want to confuse „Russian” with soviet and you perpetuate that obvious disinformation. Stop it. Whatever you were trying to talk about – and God knows I tried hard to understand – millions of Poles and Ukrainians, Jews and Russians, were killed by murderous commie bastards and their nationality was of secondary importance.

And now to the last sentence… I sense an attempt at irony here but I’m not sure because irony can hardly be delivered with a battleaxe. So perhaps I will say that: spare the irony! Just try and articulate instead, because creative articulation can be conducive to an intelligent discussion, whereas empty rhetoric and multiple question marks cannot. And, please, spare Józef Mackiewicz. If you’d really wished to find out what he had to say just read him. He wrote in many languages and was translated into even more, as long as you do not apply the idiocy of mechanical translation like google translate, you should be able to get it.

that the monster which is a REGIME in Russia today

IS RUSSIA AT 100%.

I had this argument with many of them, the last figure who was passionately enough convincing me in this was Yakov Krotov.

There are numerous sources written about Russian history tha al;ways maintained the idea that Russia as soon as it separated from Kyiv Rus became exactly THIS, forgive me for not describing this Hell redundantly again and again

It was well done by MANY and all of us know the names. In a tiny detail including details on pathological lies that so many Russians tell so often, cruelty, rating on others to the authority in power and on and on..

It may be that your naive and wishful thinking on the matter is very human and kind BUT is based on the fact that you never actually experienced Russian life.

Russians did suffer from communism a lot. My estimation is that 50% of the population of Russian empire were exterminated by communists

But they did support communism in big numbers and after all communism won and `good Russians` lost this battle and it seems that there is going to be another round of Russian offense. This time under 3-color banner and with a fake czar-figure whoever the modern Russian kgb elite will choose. He may very well be some Romanov character or a fake one for that matter.

I can only imagine how hard it will be to explain to innocent people in Poland that those nukes that (God forbid) leveled Warsaw and Krakow were delivered

NOT BY RUSSIAN rockets

build NOT BY RUSSIAN engineers

launched NOT BY RUSSIAN ARMY

and that several millions Polish citizenz kill;ed NOT BY RUSSIAN MURDEROUS BASTARDS

but by…whom??????????????

You may very well think about what you going to tell to your people now because you may not have enough time, my friends.

I wonder what in the hypothetical situation above would Pan Józef Mackiewicz tell his people?